Review: Phoenix #1

Note: Since this review was first written, evidence has surfaced that indicates several of artist Alessandro Miracolo’s character designs were traced from art in previous Marvel comics. I have left my original review as is, but I feel it is important to acknowledge these accusations as plagiarism of any kind is unacceptable.

Jean’s solo series has finally arrived, courtesy of writer Stephanie Phillips, artist Alessandro Miracolo, colorist David Curiel, & letterer Cory Petit. This debut issue sets the stage for Jean Grey’s cosmic adventure, prominently showcasing her charting her own path.

Phillips’ script establishes Jean as a powerful, self-assured hero in both her superhero & personal life, particularly in a poignant conversation w/ Scott who is back on Earth. This exchange highlights Jean’s determination & newfound confidence, making her decision to leave her life on Earth behind feel like a natural progression.

Miracolo’s portrayal of Jean is breathtaking, exuding confidence, strength, & elegance. The way Jean moves is a sight to behold, with a sense of grace & fluidity reminiscent of a ballerina. This approach adds an ethereal quality to Jean’s actions, setting her apart as a truly otherworldly hero. When Jean unleashes the Phoenix Force, Miracolo & Curiel’s collaboration truly shines. The artwork radiates intense energy, perfectly capturing the fiery power of the Phoenix in vivid imagery.

While Phillips’ writing is engaging, the choice of narrator felt misguided for a debut issue. By not using Jean’s own perspective, her autonomy & agency felt slightly diminished. Outside of her dialogue, I found it hard to fully connect w/ Jean’s thoughts. That wasn’t helped by her only appearing on about 50% of the issue’s pages. Even when not visible in a panel, I would have loved to hear more of her POV to really frame this book’s long-term thesis.

Rating: 7/10