Derby Comics

View Original

Review: Rise of the Powers of X #3

The Krakoan Era has been building towards a monumental showdown between Professor X & Moira for months now, but Rise of the Powers of X #3 fails to land the moment with a lot left to be desired.

The core conflict revolving around Xavier's descent into morally ambiguous territory has been one of the more interesting stories throughout Fall of X. His dream of a mutant utopia has become so twisted that he's willing to sacrifice lives to achieve his goals. This raises a chilling question: has Xavier become the very thing he once fought against? The internal struggle within Charles is palpable throughout the issue. Kieron Gillen crafts a tense atmosphere during the aforementioned meeting w/ Moira. The "will-he-or-won't-he" standoff kept me at the edge of my seat, but I was wholly dissatisfied w/ Rasputin IV coming in to disrupt things. It shielded Xavier from truly facing the consequences of his actions, robbing the scene of its emotional weight.

The other half of the book focusing on Moira’s conversations w/ Enigma was bogged down w/ convoluted sci-fi speak that has become a hallmark of this mini. Each new layer of Enigma’s plan that’s revealed feels like a deus ex machina of sorts to keep the story going. It’s one thing to not know what’s going on to create a sense of uneasiness or surprise. It’s another thing to never set the stage & let us as readers understand the rules of the game.

R.B. Silva’s designs & David Curiel’s colors continue to be worthy of the cover price themselves. Their are some truly epic panels featuring Rachel & team fending off Sentinels while Xavier is on his mission. Silva’s ability to convey motion is fully present throughout the action. And Curiel’s colors make every scene pop off the page.

Overall, this mini continues to be a mixed bag of unrealized potential. Gillen is trying his best, yet he’s up against months of head-scratching narrative decisions that he’s now being asked to land smoothly.

Rating: 7.5/10